Comments. Hope I didnt miss any.
Edit: thanks for the compliments dahk. To everyone: every track that I listened to was nice to listen to, these are just a few things that stuck out in my mind. The stuff below might sound nitpicky but that's how I like feedback...return the favor & do me some damage so I can learn faster
.
Grafik: real nice flip. Mellow sounding in a good way. The soloed horns work beautifully and are transitioned into well.
KnoxRaw: I like the melody, but the F and G (second and third notes) seem off beat. Didn’t really like the acapella add, but that might just be me. Well done overall.
Harlem/Philo: The kick and snare are a little loud for my taste, but they definitely bring out a sweet rhythm. Other than that this was well done. The strings work well, but the second layer of horns seems a bit discordant.
Specialist: I didn’t hear the original sample but the beat is tight.
PG: Simply awesome. Shakers seem to get rather repetitive after a while (if I’m not mistaken, throughout it’s a 4/4 pattern with one on each quarter) but only if you focus on them. The arrangement is simply gorgeous, I’m loving it.
5th Sequence: Nice, extremely clean. The layering is subtle but effective.
Ruimixx: Tight. Creative and a little hard to follow, but that’s kind of the spirit of jazz music
. As such, I can’t really envision an MC on this, but that’s not a bad thing; the beat lives, breathes, and grows on its own. Very RJD2. With that being said, I personally would make the melody a bit more pronounced.
ABC: Awesome! When the drums come in, it’s definitely on some next shit. I’d finish it if I were you.
Slik: Bassline is a little loud for my taste. Nicely flipped. I agree with ProducerGyal, hearing the drop out after 1:49 is fresh.
Dahkter: Really digging the second half of the first beat you posted. The second one is very unique, and portrays a nice sense of darkness.
G2: The horns seem a bit off beat, but the flip brings out a nice melody. I felt that in the second half the high A, C, and D horn notes could’ve been integrated better rhythmically. I’d pick a grittier sounding kick.
CMP: It’s a good start, especially for being done quickly. I’d go ahead and finish it. Awesome flip, late night riding indeed.