Im only going to address these points...If you agree with everything LDB says thats cool too and before we go any futher with this let me say that I speak for myself and I got much respect for what you're doing in the game (I've seen your other posts).
1. What is underground? To me we're talking about 2 different entities. To me underground scenes are just that...under-ground. There is no REAL market for underground so that kinda takes care of that, I mean if it's truely underground then major radio won't effect it right?
2. You said "there are a few guys who are choosing to rap about their actual life and they are being praised heavily (almost over-rated) for that choice" . The guys that are choosing to rap about their actual life are the guys that I was refering to in the original post when I said that Im liking the trend that Im seeing. "they are being praised heavily (almost over-rated)" to me that means there is a market for that, it also means that somebody is listening and liking what they hear...its being accepted, feel me?
3. You said "What I do see as a positive is the fact that the internet has allowed movements such as Grind Time Battles to grow into a nationwide situation" That is what I was refering to when I said that if the performance tax passes, these are alternatives to listening to mainstream music. At some point, you gotta accept change or die with the old way of doing things. The way I see it, hip hop didn't start in the mainstream and it was alive, it can go back to not being mainstream and survive. Im sorry but I can't agree with radio or mainstream being the one true and only source that will keep hip hop alive. Maybe Im just wishful thinking but thats where hope for anything begins in my book.
dac
LDB is right in regards to the Performance Tax, whether I agree with it or not. It will have a monumental impact on hip hop music as a genre (not culture). If corporations don't find a new way to make money from hip hop after the Performance Tax, then hip hop will become the new disco.
It's ok that you like the new direction of certain artists, it doesn't mean that the entire game is shifting that way which is what a resurgence would be defined as.
#2.) I said: My opinion is that
I don't see a resurgence of "real hip-hop" music overall. If anything, there are a few guys who are choosing to rap about their actual life and they are being praised heavily (almost over-rated) for that choice.
From what I see, most "new rappers" who are considered a "breath of fresh air to the game"
for their "subject matter" and "realistic views on life" are given an extra push by independent media outlets (bloggers/sites) because they strongly dislike the music currently dominating,
not because of their music is groundbreaking in anyway, shape, or form. It's almost like Revenge of the Bloggers. It's their way of maintaining "balance", almost like a NBA who gives a team a "make up call" for something that happened earlier in the game.
Just because fans praise, doesn't mean they will actually buy, and the majority of new artists have ridiculously low sales despite "internet buzz". Music is a business driven by numbers and before you see a resurgence, you have to look at what the Vets in the game are doing and from what I can see David Banner's new album w/ 9th Wonder and Young Jeezy's last album were the only few mainstream releases with any sort of socially conscious or reality rap point of view that would be considered a departure from their normal sound.
#1.) What is Underground? There are many different definitions to that. I point to the era of the Soundbombing/Rawkus time period as the last great era of underground hip-hop.
I was "classically trained" as an Underground Afficianado by being the "News Guy" over at
Undergroundhiphop.com (
www.ughh.com) which at the time, was the #1 hip hop site
in the world in terms of active members. Still a very credible site and hip hop institution.
When I mention Underground, that's my reference point.
The G-Unit/Smack DVD era was so powerful that it killed off the underground in NYC in that the artists felt that in order to "get on", they had to sound like 50 Cent.
Other markets such as Houston have maintained super powerful underground scenes but many others remained clones.
Radio/Performance Tax has an impact on the Underground too. You have to realize that the terms Underground and Independent are in direct relation to radio play and major label affiliation.
3.) Radio is a big part of the current equation but of course there will be other outlets that will become more prominent. You can also look to see corporate ownership of all major internet radio platform either directly by the major labels or by companies affiliated with them.