Well, you can look for Joe Chamber's "Mind Rain", which was sampled in that song. Perhaps also look for Kool & The Gang's "N.T.", Clyde McPhatter's "Mixed Up Cup", Whatnauts' "Why Can't People Be Colors Too?", Clarke Stanley's "Slow Dance" and Power of Zeus' "Sorcerer of Isis", as these are other drum samples featured on Illmatic that carry some of the same style.
Otherwise, I would just listen to other Primo productions from the same time, and see if you can jack some pure drums...that's if you not going to layer and eq or compress your own drums to make them sound similar.
Hope I helped a little.